Thursday, November 3, 2016

When Your Agent Says "NO", by Hilary Wagner





You've battled through what may be the toughest step in your writing career to date. You landed an agent. You have representation, something to be very proud of. Next step: get published. Okay, an equally tough step...correction, even tougher. 

So what do you do when your own agent tells you "no"? In other words, your manuscript isn't clicking with him or her and they don't think your work is ready to send off to editors or maybe your latest manuscript is a complete bust and in their opinion shouldn't be sent at all.
It happens...and it hurts. 

Whether you've been published before or you're still trying to get published, a great agent is going to tell you when your work isn't up to par and should not be sent off to editors. If your agent truly respects you, they're going to tell you the truth no matter what. Agents only get paid when their writers get published, so a candid agent is truly looking after your best interests. The last thing you want is an agent throwing your work against editors' walls, just in the hopes something sticks, and here's why... many times, once and editor rejects a writer's work, they don't want to see work from that writer again. Of course there are exceptions, but why risk it? You've worked far too hard to land an agent, so listen to them, because once an editor from your favorite publishing house gives the dreaded "no", it could mean no forever. 



So, what do you do?

Talk it out with your agent. What were the major issues? Best case scenario your manuscript is salvageable. Perhaps your storyline went meandering in the middle or there's simply too many characters to keep track of. Some of the best books out there were completely rewritten several times over before they made it into print. Worst case, your agent thinks there not much worth saving and your manuscript will never see the light of day. If that's the situation, as much as it might sting, appreciate your agent's honesty, learn from your mistakes, pull yourself up by the proverbial bootstraps and get going on something new. Whether you spent months or even years on a manuscript you need to move on--as hard as that may be--and many times the best books come out of crushing disappoint and a new found fire.

Okay, but despite all of the above your heart is still dead set on getting this manuscript published, even after your agent says it's a no-go. Agents are agents for good reason, they know their craft, and an editor's thoughts will generally echo what your agent is thinking, but that's not always the case, so if you're still sure your manuscript is solid gold, at the very least compromise. Ask your agent if they'd be willing to share with one or two editors before completely letting it go. If feedback comes back similar to what your agent said, thank them profusely for helping you dodge a bullet! 

Bear in mind, even bestselling authors get told no by their agents or editors. It happens all the time. Nobody's perfect!



Long story short, we all want to succeed in this business and in order to do that we need to hear the good, the bad, and the very ugly when it comes to our work. Some of the most well published writers will tell you they've had some stinkers that have never and will never see the light of day, so don't despair. Once you get into your new story, you'll feel you have a new lease on life. 

A writer friend of mine, who is now a published mystery writer, has a wonderful mantra that we all need to follow. "Never give up! Never surrender!" 

Now get out there and write!

8 comments:

  1. Great, helpful post, Hilary. Whenever I'm tempted to complain about the problems at my rung of the authorial ladder, I always think about all the challenges people at other places in their journey face.

    There never cease to be obstacles for everyone, from the raw newbie to the award-winning NYT best-seller. And it definitely helps to have someone wise and experienced in your corner to sort stuff out and give perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agreed! Honesty hurts, but it's so needed. And the bestsellers started as no-sellers. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lovely post. I would add the caution that sometimes the issue is about sensibility rather than quality. It may be that your agent is saving you a misstep, but it may also be that you aren't (or are no longer) a good fit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is very true! Yet another reason why frank discussions are so important. Thanks, Cynthia!

      Delete
  4. Enjoyed the post. Sometimes it's also a question of the wrong agent for the material. A good agent should also tell you that. In any case without an agent enthusiastic about your book a sale will be even more difficult. I so agree with you that talking with your agent to get context is so important in order to make a decision about what to do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep. If you came in as an MG author, your agent may not take to your YA. So continuing to make sure there is a similar mindset is vital. Thanks, Joe!

      Delete
  5. Thank you, Hilary! With every manuscript, I have those moments of being choked up by comments like 'This part has to go' or "This doesn't work'! I had a whole second story line in the last book that, after much hand wringing and begging, I finally removed- and they were right! That said, if you feel that YOU are right, you will hopefully have an editor or agent who will leave the door open and reconsider. It can go both ways.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Totally agree! There are amazing books that agents have rejected. It's all so subjective and it's hard to remember that. Thanks, Eden!

      Delete

Thanks for adding to the mayhem!